top of page

Is Resisting an Executive Officer a Felony in California? Penal Code 69 Explained

20 minutes ago
10 min read

The short answer: resisting an executive officer under Penal Code section 69 is a wobbler, which means the District Attorney can file it as a felony punishable by county jail under the realignment sentencing scheme or as a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in county jail. It is the felony cousin of misdemeanor resisting arrest under Penal Code section 148, and the difference comes down to threats and force. Prosecutors in Riverside, San Bernardino, and Los Angeles County file section 69 when an arrest turned physical, and these cases are won or lost on body camera footage and the question of whether the officer was acting lawfully at the moment of the struggle.

What Penal Code Section 69 Prohibits

Section 69 covers two different acts. The statute makes it a crime to attempt, by means of any threat or violence, to deter or prevent an executive officer from performing any duty imposed by law, or to knowingly resist, by the use of force or violence, an executive officer in the performance of that duty. The California Supreme Court confirmed in In re Manuel G. (1997) 16 Cal.4th 805 that these are two separate ways to violate the section, and that the threat branch does not require the officer to be performing a duty at the moment of the threat as long as the threat is aimed at deterring a future duty.

Executive officer means more than police. An executive officer is a government official who may use their own discretion in performing their duties. Police officers, sheriff's deputies, and California Highway Patrol officers are the usual alleged victims, but the term also reaches prosecutors, judges, probation officers, and other officials. In the Inland Empire the charge most often arises from an encounter with the Riverside County Sheriff's Department, the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department, or a city police department in Riverside, Fontana, Rancho Cucamonga, Victorville, or Hesperia.

The jury instruction splits the two theories. Judges typically instruct with CALCRIM 2651 for the threat theory and CALCRIM 2652 for the force theory, and the prosecutor must tell the jury which theory is being pursued or prove both. That distinction matters for the defense, because the evidence needed to prove a threat is very different from the evidence needed to prove forcible resistance.

What the Prosecutor Must Prove Beyond a Reasonable Doubt

For the threat theory, the elements are these. The prosecutor must prove (1) that you willfully and unlawfully used violence or a threat of violence to try to prevent or deter an executive officer from performing a lawful duty, and (2) that when you acted, you intended to prevent or deter the officer from performing that duty. The threat may be spoken, written, or implied by conduct, and it does not have to be carried out, but it must be a threat of violence rather than a threat to file a complaint or sue.

For the force theory, the elements are these. The prosecutor must prove (1) that you unlawfully used force or violence to resist an executive officer, (2) that when you acted, the officer was performing a lawful duty, and (3) that when you acted, you knew the person was an executive officer who was performing that duty. The lawful duty element is where most defenses live, because an officer who is using unreasonable force or making an unlawful detention or arrest is not performing a lawful duty.

Force means more than passive resistance. Going limp, refusing to put your hands behind your back, or tensing up can support a misdemeanor charge under Penal Code section 148, but they are not the force or violence required for section 69. Pulling away, striking, kicking, head-butting, or wrestling an officer is the kind of conduct the District Attorney points to in a felony filing. The California Supreme Court held in People v. Smith (2013) 57 Cal.4th 232 that section 148 is not a lesser included offense of section 69 under the statutory elements test, because a section 69 violation can be committed by a threat alone without any actual resistance.

Penal Code 69 Compared With Penal Code 148 and 243(b)

Section 148 is the misdemeanor version. Penal Code section 148 punishes willfully resisting, delaying, or obstructing a peace officer, and it does not require force. It is a misdemeanor only, and it is the charge that most often results from arguing, walking away, or refusing to comply. Many section 69 cases are reduced to section 148 at the pretrial stage when the footage does not show real force.

Battery on an officer is the companion charge. Penal Code section 243 includes battery on a peace officer, which is a misdemeanor without injury and a wobbler when the officer is injured, as we explain in Battery on a Police Officer in California. Prosecutors frequently file section 69 and section 243 together from the same struggle, and a plea negotiation often involves dismissing one in exchange for a plea to the other.

Assault on an officer can be added. Penal Code section 241 covers assault on a peace officer, and if a weapon or force likely to cause great bodily injury was involved, assault with a deadly weapon under Penal Code section 245 can be charged with a peace officer enhancement. The more counts the District Attorney files, the more important it becomes to attack the lawful performance element that runs through all of them.

Defenses to a Penal Code 69 Charge

The officer used excessive force. An officer who uses unreasonable force is not performing a lawful duty, and a person may use reasonable force to defend against it. The standard for reasonable police force comes from Graham v. Connor (1989) 490 U.S. 386, which asks whether the force was objectively reasonable given the severity of the crime, the threat posed, and whether the person was actively resisting or fleeing. When there is evidence of excessive force, the jury must be instructed on it, and the prosecution must prove lawful performance beyond a reasonable doubt.

The detention or arrest was unlawful. If the officer had no reasonable suspicion to detain you or no probable cause to arrest you, the officer was not performing a lawful duty, and the force element fails. This is why a section 69 case begins with the same Fourth Amendment analysis used in a motion to suppress under Penal Code section 1538.5, and why the facts of the initial stop, described in Can Police Lie to You During an Interrogation in California?, matter as much as the struggle itself.

There was no threat of violence. Angry words, profanity, and promises to sue or report the officer are protected speech and are not threats of violence. A threat theory case built on an insult or a complaint about the officer's conduct does not satisfy section 69, and the defense should force the prosecutor to identify the exact words alleged.

You did not know the person was an officer. Plainclothes officers, unmarked cars, and chaotic scenes produce cases where a person pushed back against someone they did not recognize as law enforcement. Knowledge is an element, and the prosecutor must prove it.

The resistance was not willful or was not force. Reflexive movements during a takedown, flinching from pain, or being pulled in two directions by two officers are not willful force. Body camera footage frequently shows that the person charged with felony resisting was being held down and was not fighting at all. Our guide What Makes a Criminal Case Weak in California explains how video undermines the narrative in a police report.

Self-defense against unlawful force. California recognizes the right to use reasonable force to resist an officer's excessive force, as discussed in our guide to self-defense in California criminal law. The force used must be proportionate, and the defense does not extend to resisting a lawful arrest simply because you believe you are innocent.

How the Defense Investigates a Resisting Case

Body camera and dash camera footage come first. Under Penal Code section 1054.1, the prosecution must disclose the evidence it intends to use and any exculpatory evidence, and the defense should demand every angle of video, the computer-aided dispatch log, radio traffic, and the use of force report. Agencies in Riverside and San Bernardino County now equip most patrol officers with body cameras, and the footage, not the report, decides these cases. See How Does Discovery Work in a California Criminal Case? for the process.

A Pitchess motion can reach the officer's history. When excessive force is the defense, Evidence Code section 1043 and Evidence Code section 1045 allow a Pitchess motion seeking prior complaints of excessive force or dishonesty from the officer's personnel file. The court reviews the records in chambers and discloses the names of complaining witnesses when the records are relevant. This is standard practice in section 69 cases and should be filed early.

Medical records and photographs document injuries. Your own injuries are evidence of the force the officer used. Photographs taken the day of the arrest, emergency room records, and witness statements from bystanders who recorded the encounter on their phones often change the trajectory of a case at the pretrial conference.

Penalties and Collateral Consequences

As a felony, section 69 is punishable under the realignment scheme. A felony conviction carries a term served in county jail under Penal Code section 1170, subdivision (h), with the possibility of probation, and a felony record that affects firearm rights under Penal Code section 29800 for life. A misdemeanor conviction carries up to one year in county jail, probation, fines, and conditions.

Reduction to a misdemeanor is common. Because section 69 is a wobbler, the court may reduce a felony to a misdemeanor at sentencing or later under Penal Code section 17, subdivision (b), as we explain in How to Reduce a Felony to a Misdemeanor in California. Prosecutors in Riverside County and San Bernardino County frequently agree to a misdemeanor section 69 or a section 148 plea in cases without officer injury.

Collateral consequences are significant. A conviction for resisting with force is viewed harshly by employers, licensing boards, and immigration authorities, and Penal Code section 1016.3 requires your lawyer to advise you about immigration consequences before any plea. A felony conviction also carries a lifetime firearm ban, and even a misdemeanor conviction appears on background checks until it is addressed through expungement under Penal Code section 1203.4.

Diversion may be available. Penal Code section 1001.95 misdemeanor diversion does not exclude section 148 or a misdemeanor section 69, so a case reduced to a misdemeanor may be eligible for diversion and dismissal. Mental health diversion under Penal Code section 1001.36 can apply to felony section 69 cases when a qualifying condition contributed to the encounter, which is common in cases arising from mental health crises.

How These Cases Move Through Southern California Courts

Felony filings start with arraignment and a preliminary hearing. A felony section 69 case filed at the Riverside Hall of Justice, the San Bernardino Justice Center, the Victorville courthouse, or the Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center in downtown Los Angeles begins with arraignment, followed by a preliminary hearing at which the officer usually testifies. Cross-examining the officer on the footage at the preliminary hearing often produces the first realistic offer, and a magistrate may reduce the charge to a misdemeanor at that stage under Penal Code section 17, subdivision (b).

Misdemeanor filings move faster. A misdemeanor section 69 or section 148 case goes from arraignment to a pretrial conference and, if no resolution is reached, to trial. Officers are generally credible witnesses in front of juries, but juries also watch video closely, and a case that looked strong in the report often looks very different after the footage is played in a courtroom in Riverside, Rancho Cucamonga, or Van Nuys.

Mistakes to avoid. Do not post about the incident on social media, do not contact the officer or the agency to complain before speaking with counsel, and do not give a recorded statement to internal affairs investigators without a lawyer. Each of those steps creates evidence, as we explain in Do Not Say This to Police in California. Preserve your own injuries with photographs and medical visits, and gather the names of anyone who recorded the encounter.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Penal Code 69 a felony or a misdemeanor?

Either. Penal Code section 69 is a wobbler, so the District Attorney may file it as a felony or a misdemeanor, and a judge may reduce a felony to a misdemeanor under Penal Code section 17, subdivision (b). Felony filings are common when an officer was injured or when the person is alleged to have struck the officer.

What is the difference between Penal Code 69 and Penal Code 148?

Force and threats. Penal Code section 148 punishes resisting, delaying, or obstructing an officer in any way and is a misdemeanor only. Penal Code section 69 requires either a threat of violence intended to deter the officer or actual force or violence used to resist, and it may be filed as a felony.

Can I be convicted of Penal Code 69 if the officer used excessive force?

Not if the force was unreasonable. An officer who uses excessive force is not performing a lawful duty, and lawful performance is an element the prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt. The standard comes from Graham v. Connor, and the jury must be instructed on excessive force when the evidence supports it.

Does resisting an executive officer count as a strike in California?

Generally no. Penal Code section 69 is not listed as a serious or violent felony, so a conviction standing alone is not a strike under the Three Strikes law. A related conviction for assault with a deadly weapon or an enhancement for great bodily injury can change that, so review every count with counsel.

Can a Penal Code 69 charge be reduced or dismissed?

Often, yes. Common outcomes include reduction to misdemeanor Penal Code section 148, a misdemeanor section 69 with probation, misdemeanor diversion under Penal Code section 1001.95 after reduction, or dismissal when the footage shows an unlawful detention or excessive force. The outcome depends heavily on the video and on the officer's injuries, if any.

Will I lose my gun rights after a Penal Code 69 conviction?

For a felony, yes. A felony conviction imposes a lifetime firearm ban under Penal Code section 29800. A misdemeanor conviction under section 69 does not carry the lifetime felony ban, but related misdemeanor convictions can trigger a ten-year prohibition under Penal Code section 29805, so confirm the consequences of any plea before you enter it.

Gramling Law Group defends resisting, battery on an officer, and assault charges at the Riverside Hall of Justice, the Southwest Justice Center in Murrieta, the San Bernardino Justice Center, the Rancho Cucamonga courthouse, the Victorville courthouse, the Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center, and courthouses throughout the Inland Empire, Los Angeles County, Orange County, and Southern California. Daniel Gramling, Esq. offers flat-fee criminal defense and limited-scope options so that you know the cost before the first hearing. Call (909) 654-4575 or contact us through this website for a consultation.

This article is educational and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. It addresses California law only.

Related Guides From Gramling Law Group

Learn more about our criminal defense practice serving the Inland Empire, Los Angeles County, and Southern California.

We defend Penal Code section 69 and resisting cases in Riverside, San Bernardino, Victorville, and Los Angeles. See our Riverside criminal defense attorney, San Bernardino criminal defense attorney, and Victorville criminal defense attorney pages, and our Inland Empire criminal defense overview.

Gramling Law Group

3600 Lime St, Bldg 2, Riverside, CA 92501

Serving the Inland Empire, Los Angeles County, Orange County, and all of Southern California except San Diego in family law and criminal defense.

Follow Daniel Gramling on Instagram: @californiafamilylawyer

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

​​

Office: 1200 California Street, Suite 114, Redlands, CA 92374

Phone: (213) 255-4780 · Serving Riverside, San Bernardino, Los Angeles and Orange County

All information from this site is educational only and shall not be construed as legal advice nor shall it constitute the creation of an attorney client relationship. All sales are final, there shall be no refunds of any products purchased. 

bottom of page